Customers can pay $1 or more for the Dreamcast Collection (SEGA Bass Fishing, Crazy Taxi, Sonic Adventure DX Director's Cut, and Space Channel 5 Part 2), NiGHTS Into Dreams, Sonic & All-Stars Racing Transformed, Total War: ROME II - Caesar in Gaul, and the Miles Jacobson Tactic DLC for Football Manager 2015 — exclusive Total War: Attila wallpapers also included at this tier.  

Those who pay more than the average price will also receive Empire: Total War and Company of Heroes 2 - The Western Front Armies: Oberkommando West. Customers who pay $12 or more will receive all of the above plus Total War: Shogun 2 - Fall of the Samurai, and those who pay $50 or more will also receive a limited edition Dreamcast t-shirt from Fangamer. Additional titles will be unveiled mid-promotion increasing the bundle's value even more.

As with all Humble Bundles, customers can choose how their purchase dollars are allocated, between the publisher and charity. The Humble SEGA Bundle supports four charitable causes — AbleGamers, Willow Foundation, SpecialEffect, and GamesAid.